Discourse Blog

Discourse Blog

Share this post

Discourse Blog
Discourse Blog
The Traitors at the New York Times
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
User's avatar
Discover more from Discourse Blog
A daily politics, media criticism, and culture newsletter from the left. Worker-owned, subscriber-supported, and free from corporate influence. Est. 2020.
Over 22,000 subscribers
Already have an account? Sign in

The Traitors at the New York Times

Peter Baker and Michael Shear scabbed during a staff walkout. There is no more vile betrayal than that.

Jack Mirkinson's avatar
Jack Mirkinson
Dec 08, 2022
36

Share this post

Discourse Blog
Discourse Blog
The Traitors at the New York Times
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
4
Share
Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images

Today, over 1,100 workers at the New York Times went on strike for 24 hours. The walkout—the first of its kind at the paper in four decades—is happening largely because ordinary Times workers are underpaid, and because Times management is offering paltry salary increases even as the New York Times Company makes tidy profits and pays its executives millions.

Twitter

Discourse Blog is an independent, reader-funded, worker-owned, union-loving publication. Please consider supporting our work by subscribing.

Over 1,000 people don’t make a collective decision to walk off the job lightly, even for one day. When you’re bargaining a contract, you wind up talking a lot about “the escalation ladder”—the ever-bolder steps you are prepared to take if management isn’t playing ball. Walking out is almost always at or near the very top of that ladder. It’s never your first move. There are lots of smaller steps that come first. Nobody goes into bargaining expecting that they’ll have to strike. It’s a brave, high-stakes decision, a deliberate provocation, and it doesn’t happen unless workers truly feel like they are out of options.

Twitter
Twitter

That is why, when workers do decide to strike, it’s so important to support them and to honor their demands—no matter whether they’re working in a factory or at a citadel of the elite like the New York Times. (White collar workers are exploited too, and any attempt to say otherwise is a form of manipulative class warfare that you should not indulge in.) The demands made by the Times staffers were simple: if you’re in the union, don’t work on Thursday, and if you’re not, don’t engage with any Times content, in print or online, for the whole day. (If you did the Wordle today, sorry, but you crossed a picket line.)

Thank you for reading Discourse Blog. This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share

It’s not an indefinite strike—it’s a one-day show of force, and the more people who participate, the more likely it is that the workers can succeed, which benefits everybody. This is not, on the whole, too much to ask.

The grim flip-side to supporting a strike is, of course, scabbing. If standing with your fellow employees is one of the noblest things a person can do, then scabbing is one of the most disgusting—a sign that your moral and ethical compass is rotted to the core, that your solidarity only stretches as far as your own personal self-interest. It is a signal to your colleagues that you are not to be trusted, that you will sell them out, and that you are willing to undermine their struggle for rights and dignity. It is the choice that a traitor makes.

This brings me to Peter Baker and Michael Shear, two White House correspondents for the Times. As Semafor’s Max Tani reported on Thursday, Baker and Shear informed their co-workers that they would not participate in the walkout. They then proceeded to file their copy as if it was any other day at the paper. In other words, they scabbed. They spit in their colleagues’ faces. They sided with management against their own union. They weakened the union’s leverage against the Times’ bosses.

Baker is well-known for adhering so scrupulously to dumb notions of objectivity that he refuses to vote in elections, lest it color his sainted political neutrality. Apparently, though, crossing a picket line doesn’t feel like an ideological stance to him. Funny how that works.

Baker and Shear occupy some of the loftiest perches at the Times. I don’t know what their salary is, but it’s a safe bet that they don’t belong to the group of Times staffers making under $50,000. (Shear infamously signed a letter opposing the removal of a cap on union dues for employees making more than $140,000 a year, so no prizes for guessing what he brings in.) They would have lost nothing by honoring the walkout, and they would have sent a message that, even though the wage fight was not primarily about their well-being, they cared enough about the people whose labor supports their work to stand alongside them for a mere 24 hours.

Instead, Baker and Shear scabbed.

There are no epithets strong enough to describe how reprehensible it is to do what Baker and Shear did today. It was an act of deliberate malice against their co-workers, most of whom surely have less power at the Times than they do. I fervently hope that Times staffers win their fight, and get the wages they deserve. And I fervently hope that Baker and Shear’s vile behavior is never forgotten. Scabbing is the ultimate betrayal. It is a mark of eternal shame, and they will wear it forever.


Subscribe to Discourse Blog

Thousands of paid subscribers
A daily politics, media criticism, and culture newsletter from the left. Worker-owned, subscriber-supported, and free from corporate influence. Est. 2020.
Alex Speidel's avatar
chloe's avatar
Caitlin Schneider's avatar
Aram Zucker-Scharff's avatar
Samantha Grasso's avatar
36 Likes
36

Share this post

Discourse Blog
Discourse Blog
The Traitors at the New York Times
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
4
Share

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dave Infante's avatar
Dave Infante
Dec 8, 2022

"Ah, boots for breakfast, my favorite"—Peter Baker

Expand full comment
Like (4)
Reply
Share
1 reply
Alexandra's avatar
Alexandra
Dec 9, 2022

Scabs are the lowest of the low. Disgusting behavior.

Expand full comment
Like (2)
Reply
Share
2 more comments...
Bari Weiss Is Full of Shit
Her big trans panic story turned out to be nonsense, just like everything else she does.
Mar 2, 2023 • 
Katherine Krueger
304

Share this post

Discourse Blog
Discourse Blog
Bari Weiss Is Full of Shit
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
5
CNN's Disgraceful Propaganda
This segment from Dana Bash on the Palestine protest movement is one of the most shameful things I have ever seen on cable news.
May 2, 2024 • 
Jack Mirkinson
136

Share this post

Discourse Blog
Discourse Blog
CNN's Disgraceful Propaganda
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
55
No Hell Is Hot Enough for Joe Biden
I hope he’s faced with the horror he’s wrought when judgment comes to meet him.
Jan 17 • 
Katherine Krueger
84

Share this post

Discourse Blog
Discourse Blog
No Hell Is Hot Enough for Joe Biden
Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More
4

Ready for more?

© 2025 Discourse Blog Inc.
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Copy link
Facebook
Email
Notes
More

Create your profile

User's avatar

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.